Mon, 24 Jun 2019
Dooplaya Incident Report: Two Tatmadaw deserters killed seven civilians in Win Yay Township, April 2019

On 5th April 2019, two Tatmadaw deserters shot eight Muslim civilians from W--- village over a motorbike dispute. Seven of them died, but no compensation was provided to the families for their deceased relatives. Local civilians are now worried about their security[1].

Part 1 - Incident Details

Type of IndidentType of Indident
Multiple killingsMultiple killings
Type of IndidentDate of Incident(s)
Multiple killingsApril 5th 2019
Type of IndidentIncident Location (Village, Township and District)
Multiple killingsW---Village, Win Yay Township, Dooplaya District 
Type of Indident Multiple killings
Date of Incident(s) April 5th 2019
Incident Location (Village, Township and District) W---Village, Win Yay Township, Dooplaya District 
Victim InformationVictim Information
Victim InformationName
Ma K---
Maung M---
Daw S---
Daw P--- (survived)
Victim InformationAge
3
1
38
36
Victim InformationSex
Female
Male
Female
Female
Victim InformationFamily
Single
Single
Married
Married
Victim InformationOccupation
Dependant
Dependant 
Dependant
Dependant
Victim InformationReligion
Islam
Islam
Islam
Islam
Victim InformationPosition
Villager
Villager
Villager
Villager
Victim InformationVillage
W---
W---
W---
W---
Victim Information
Name Ma K--- Maung M--- Daw S--- Daw P--- (survived)
Age 3 1 38 36
Sex Female Male Female Female
Family Single Single Married Married
Occupation Dependant Dependant  Dependant Dependant
Religion Islam Islam Islam Islam
Position Villager Villager Villager Villager
Village W--- W--- W--- W---
Victim InformationVictim Information
Victim InformationName
U L ---
U B ---
U T ---
Maung A --
Victim InformationAge
43
38
36
9
Victim InformationSex
Male
Male
Male
Male
Victim InformationFamily
Single
Married
Married
Single
Victim InformationOccupation
Motorbike Technician
Dependant
Dependant
Dependant
Victim InformationReligion
Islam
Islam
Islam
Islam
Victim InformationPosition
Villager
Villager
Villager
Villager
Victim InformationVillage
W ---
W ---
W ---
W ---
Victim Information
Name U L --- U B --- U T --- Maung A --
Age 43 38 36 9
Sex Male Male Male Male
Family Single Married Married Single
Occupation Motorbike Technician Dependant Dependant Dependant
Religion Islam Islam Islam Islam
Position Villager Villager Villager Villager
Village W --- W --- W --- W ---
Perpetrator InformationPerpetrator Information
Perpetrator InformationName
Rank
Unit
Base
Commander's Name
Perpetrator InformationNyein Chan
Soldier
LIB #275
SOC #1 W

Operations Commander Soe Moe Kyaw

Perpetrator InformationMyint Wai
Soldier
LIB #339
SOC #1 W
Operations Commander Soe Moe Kyaw
Perpetrator Information
Name Rank Unit Base Commander's Name
Nyein Chan Soldier LIB #275 SOC #1 W

Operations Commander Soe Moe Kyaw

Myint Wai Soldier LIB #339 SOC #1 W Operations Commander Soe Moe Kyaw

 

Part 2 - Information Quality 

1. Explain in detail how you collected this information.1. Explain in detail how you collected this information.
1. Explain in detail how you collected this information.The researcher met with the Karen National Union (KNU) and Karen National Police Force (KNPF) to discuss this incident. He went to the location where the killings took place and met with family members of the victims to gain more information
1. Explain in detail how you collected this information.
The researcher met with the Karen National Union (KNU) and Karen National Police Force (KNPF) to discuss this incident. He went to the location where the killings took place and met with family members of the victims to gain more information
2. Explain how the source verified this information. 2. Explain how the source verified this information. 
2. Explain how the source verified this information. The researcher collected the information about the incident from the victim’s relatives, villagers from W---, as well as staff of the KNU and KNPF
2. Explain how the source verified this information. 
The researcher collected the information about the incident from the victim’s relatives, villagers from W---, as well as staff of the KNU and KNPF

 

Part 3 - Complete Description of the Incident

Describe the Incident(s) in complete detail.Describe the Incident(s) in complete detail.
Describe the Incident(s) in complete detail.

The incident happened on April 5th 2019 outside of W--- village, Win Yay Township, Dooplaya District, in a mixed control area. Around 3:30 AM, two Tatmadaw deserters from LIB #339 and LIB #275, Nyein Chan and Myint Wai, reached a local motorbike workshop located 15 minutes away from the village. When the owner refused to give them a motorbike, one of the soldiers shot him with his service rifle.

 

The brother of the owner, who lived nearby, was also shot when he arrived at the scene. Then, the two deserters entered his house and shot a woman and children who were sleeping inside. They also shot the family members who tried to run away. In total, 7 persons were killed and one was injured. All the victims were from two local Muslim families.

 

One of the family members, U F--- managed to escape. He ran to the village and reported the case to the village administrator, U H---, who immediately called the KNPF in Hpah Prah. When the KNPF reached the crime scene at around 3:50 AM, the perpetrators were already gone. They were later arrested by the KNPF, one at a KNLA checkpoint in Lut Shan and the other one outside W--- village, and handed over to the Tatmadaw.

 

The Myanmar police from Three Pagodas Pass first banned the family from burying the dead bodies, presumably for investigation purposes. KNLA Battalion #16 ultimately allowed the family to proceed with the burials, as these should take place as soon as possible according to Islamic belief.

 

The two deserters remain in military custody awaiting trial. Tatmadaw soldiers based in the area told KHRG that they are likely to face death penalty. However, local people do not know how the Tatmadaw is processing the case. Crimes committed by military personnel are handled by Myanmar’s military justice system. Proceedings of military courts are not public, which makes it difficult to obtain reliable information about pending cases.2

 

Local people only found out about the killings in the next morning. Some of them were scared because they felt threatened by this incident. U H--- said that Tatmadaw soldiers from Strategic Operations Command’s (SOC) W--- military camp patrol every night around the village, which causes security concerns among civilians. He also said that weak leadership and management in the area contributed to this incident.

 

He recommended to put an end to the mixed control system to fix these shortcomings, and advocated for the demilitarisation of the area: “We are minorities. We should only have one ruling system. The Tatmadaw should not stay next to the village anymore. We cannot predict whether this kind of incident will happen again. If something happens, it will be dangerous for us because the Tatmadaw established their camp close to the students [children have to travel in front of the camp to go to school] and to our religious land. This can cause additional concerns whenever innocent villagers are killed.”

 

Operations Commander Soe Moe Kyaw from W--- SOC offered to give 5,000,000 kyats (USD 3267.17) to the victims’ family members in compensation, but U H--- said that they refused and asked for 10,000,000 kyats (USD 6534.35) per dead victim. As a result, no compensation was provided to the families for their deceased relatives.

 

Daw P---, a woman who was injured during the incident, was admitted to hospital at her own expenses. She has now been discharged. A local interfaith organisation helped her with 1,000,000 kyats (USD 653.44). Commander Soe Moe Kyaw also gave her 1,000,000 kyats in compensation for her injury.

Describe the Incident(s) in complete detail.

The incident happened on April 5th 2019 outside of W--- village, Win Yay Township, Dooplaya District, in a mixed control area. Around 3:30 AM, two Tatmadaw deserters from LIB #339 and LIB #275, Nyein Chan and Myint Wai, reached a local motorbike workshop located 15 minutes away from the village. When the owner refused to give them a motorbike, one of the soldiers shot him with his service rifle.

 

The brother of the owner, who lived nearby, was also shot when he arrived at the scene. Then, the two deserters entered his house and shot a woman and children who were sleeping inside. They also shot the family members who tried to run away. In total, 7 persons were killed and one was injured. All the victims were from two local Muslim families.

 

One of the family members, U F--- managed to escape. He ran to the village and reported the case to the village administrator, U H---, who immediately called the KNPF in Hpah Prah. When the KNPF reached the crime scene at around 3:50 AM, the perpetrators were already gone. They were later arrested by the KNPF, one at a KNLA checkpoint in Lut Shan and the other one outside W--- village, and handed over to the Tatmadaw.

 

The Myanmar police from Three Pagodas Pass first banned the family from burying the dead bodies, presumably for investigation purposes. KNLA Battalion #16 ultimately allowed the family to proceed with the burials, as these should take place as soon as possible according to Islamic belief.

 

The two deserters remain in military custody awaiting trial. Tatmadaw soldiers based in the area told KHRG that they are likely to face death penalty. However, local people do not know how the Tatmadaw is processing the case. Crimes committed by military personnel are handled by Myanmar’s military justice system. Proceedings of military courts are not public, which makes it difficult to obtain reliable information about pending cases.2

 

Local people only found out about the killings in the next morning. Some of them were scared because they felt threatened by this incident. U H--- said that Tatmadaw soldiers from Strategic Operations Command’s (SOC) W--- military camp patrol every night around the village, which causes security concerns among civilians. He also said that weak leadership and management in the area contributed to this incident.

 

He recommended to put an end to the mixed control system to fix these shortcomings, and advocated for the demilitarisation of the area: “We are minorities. We should only have one ruling system. The Tatmadaw should not stay next to the village anymore. We cannot predict whether this kind of incident will happen again. If something happens, it will be dangerous for us because the Tatmadaw established their camp close to the students [children have to travel in front of the camp to go to school] and to our religious land. This can cause additional concerns whenever innocent villagers are killed.”

 

Operations Commander Soe Moe Kyaw from W--- SOC offered to give 5,000,000 kyats (USD 3267.17) to the victims’ family members in compensation, but U H--- said that they refused and asked for 10,000,000 kyats (USD 6534.35) per dead victim. As a result, no compensation was provided to the families for their deceased relatives.

 

Daw P---, a woman who was injured during the incident, was admitted to hospital at her own expenses. She has now been discharged. A local interfaith organisation helped her with 1,000,000 kyats (USD 653.44). Commander Soe Moe Kyaw also gave her 1,000,000 kyats in compensation for her injury.

 

Part 4 - Permission for Using the Details 

Did the victim(s) provide permission to use this information? Explain how that permission was provided.Did the victim(s) provide permission to use this information? Explain how that permission was provided.
Did the victim(s) provide permission to use this information? Explain how that permission was provided.The relatives of the victims gave us permission to use this information.
Did the victim(s) provide permission to use this information? Explain how that permission was provided.
The relatives of the victims gave us permission to use this information.
Mon, 24 Jun 2019

Footnotes: 

[1]The present document is based on information received in May 2019. It was provided by a community member in Dooplaya District who has been trained by KHRG to monitor human rights conditions on the ground. The names of the victims, their photos and the exact locations are censored for security reasons.
 
[2]Open Democracy (December 2014), “Civilian justice trumps military impunity in Myanmar”.

Related Readings