press x to close
Karen Human Rights Group

Hpapun Incident Report: Forced relocation by the Meh Tha Lut village administrator in Bu Tho Township, May 2019

,

These two photos were taken on May 3rd, 2019 in L--- village, Meh Klaw village tract, Bu Tho Township, Hpapun District. The photo on the left shows dismantled houses after villagers were forced to relocate. The photo on the right shows their temporary settlement. [Photos: KHRG]

 

Part 1- Incident Details

Type of IncidentType of Incident
Forced relocationForced relocation
Type of IncidentDate of Incident (s)
Forced relocationMay 1st 2019
Type of Incident

Incident Location (Village, Township and District)

Forced relocationK--- (close to L--- village), Meh K'law village tract, Bu Tho Township, Mutraw District
Type of Incident Forced relocation
Date of Incident (s) May 1st 2019

Incident Location (Village, Township and District)

K--- (close to L--- village), Meh K'law village tract, Bu Tho Township, Mutraw District
Victim InformationVictim Information
Victim InformationName
Ma S---
Victim InformationAge
43
Victim InformationSex
Female
Victim InformationEthnicity
Burmese
Victim InformationFamily
Married
Victim InformationOccupation
Day labourer 
Victim InformationReligion 
Buddhist 
Victim InformationPosition
-
Victim InformationVillage
L--- Village
Victim Information
Name Ma S---
Age 43
Sex Female
Ethnicity Burmese
Family Married
Occupation Day labourer 
Religion  Buddhist 
Position -
Village L--- Village
Perpetrator Information (Civilians) Perpetrator Information (Civilians) 
Perpetrator Information (Civilians) Name (s)
Position
Location
Superior's Name
Perpetrator Information (Civilians) U Aung Myint Kyine
Meh Tha Lut village administrator
Meh Tha Lut village, Meh K'law village tract, Hpapun Township
U Chan Nyein Aye, Bu Tho Township administrator
Perpetrator Information (Civilians) 
Name (s) Position Location Superior's Name
U Aung Myint Kyine Meh Tha Lut village administrator Meh Tha Lut village, Meh K'law village tract, Hpapun Township U Chan Nyein Aye, Bu Tho Township administrator

 

Part 2 - Information Quality 

1. Explain in detail how you collected this information.1. Explain in detail how you collected this information.
1. Explain in detail how you collected this information.Ma S--- called the KHRG researcher, who went to meet with her and interviewed her. 
1. Explain in detail how you collected this information.
Ma S--- called the KHRG researcher, who went to meet with her and interviewed her. 
2. Explain how the source verified this information. 2. Explain how the source verified this information. 
2. Explain how the source verified this information. The interviewee experienced this incident first hand. 
2. Explain how the source verified this information. 
The interviewee experienced this incident first hand. 

 

Part 3 - Complete Description for the Incident

Describe the Incident(s) in complete detail. Describe the Incident(s) in complete detail. 
Describe the Incident(s) in complete detail. 

Around April 21st 2019, three people from the Ministry of Agriculture, Livestock and Irrigation (the Ministry) and the Meh Tha Lut village administrator, U[2] Aung Myint Kyine, came to K--- to survey the area for a road construction project to improve connectivity between K--- and L--- village. At the same time, villagers were also informed of this project and promised that they would each be allocated a plot of land measuring 40 x 60 feet [approximately 12.20 x 18.30 metres] in K---. The village administrator also extorted money from villagers by asking them to pay between 10,000 to 20,000 kyats [USD 6.64 and 13.28, respectively][3] to cover the cost of the road construction activities.

 

On May 1st 2019, U Aung Myint Kyine forced 87 villagers from 13 households in K--- to relocate. Many villagers have lived in the area since 2009. Although they do not possess any land titles, they obtained consent from the Karen National Union (KNU)[4] to live there. On the same day, the three people from the Ministry and the village administrator started the construction activities with bulldozers. Although the villagers did not want to leave, they dismantled their houses and built huts on other villagers’ nearby paddy fields as they had no ability to oppose the project.

 

The dismantled houses valued at a range of 50,000 to 300,000 kyats [USD 33.19 to 199.13]; and 25% of the houses were destroyed during the dismantling process. Ma S--- stated: “We were afraid that our houses were going to be destroyed by the bulldozer if we failed to move out from our place. Actually, it was not necessary to dismantle the houses. Because of this, we faced difficulties as we are a big family. They [the village administrator] intentionally forced us to relocate from this place […].”

 

While road construction activities were carried out, U Chan Nyein Aye, the Hpapun Township administrator, came to the area to monitor the situation.  He, U Aung Myint Kyine, and the three personnel from the Ministry told the villagers that they would reconstruct the houses that were destroyed and told them not to worry as it was a temporary relocation.

 

Many villagers faced difficulties at the relocation site as they had inadequate housing equipment and the newly built huts were too small for large families. Ma S--- elaborated on this problem: “These people are poor. They [the village administrator] should not have done that to them […].” Ma S--- testified that she spent 50,000 kyats [33.19 USD] to build a tent there, and elaborated on the difficulties she faced in relation to the high-cost of building the tent: “When we built it, it cost us 50,000 kyats. I had to sell goods [snacks] at the school to save money. It was for buying leaves [to make a] roof for my tent.”

 

In August 2019, villagers were allowed to return to K---. Although villagers were allocated lands in K--- after the road construction activities ceased, houses that were destroyed were not reconstructed, as promised. As of December 17th 2019, five households had returned to the village, while the others remained at the relocation site because they could not afford to rebuild their houses.

 

Describe the Incident(s) in complete detail. 

Around April 21st 2019, three people from the Ministry of Agriculture, Livestock and Irrigation (the Ministry) and the Meh Tha Lut village administrator, U[2] Aung Myint Kyine, came to K--- to survey the area for a road construction project to improve connectivity between K--- and L--- village. At the same time, villagers were also informed of this project and promised that they would each be allocated a plot of land measuring 40 x 60 feet [approximately 12.20 x 18.30 metres] in K---. The village administrator also extorted money from villagers by asking them to pay between 10,000 to 20,000 kyats [USD 6.64 and 13.28, respectively][3] to cover the cost of the road construction activities.

 

On May 1st 2019, U Aung Myint Kyine forced 87 villagers from 13 households in K--- to relocate. Many villagers have lived in the area since 2009. Although they do not possess any land titles, they obtained consent from the Karen National Union (KNU)[4] to live there. On the same day, the three people from the Ministry and the village administrator started the construction activities with bulldozers. Although the villagers did not want to leave, they dismantled their houses and built huts on other villagers’ nearby paddy fields as they had no ability to oppose the project.

 

The dismantled houses valued at a range of 50,000 to 300,000 kyats [USD 33.19 to 199.13]; and 25% of the houses were destroyed during the dismantling process. Ma S--- stated: “We were afraid that our houses were going to be destroyed by the bulldozer if we failed to move out from our place. Actually, it was not necessary to dismantle the houses. Because of this, we faced difficulties as we are a big family. They [the village administrator] intentionally forced us to relocate from this place […].”

 

While road construction activities were carried out, U Chan Nyein Aye, the Hpapun Township administrator, came to the area to monitor the situation.  He, U Aung Myint Kyine, and the three personnel from the Ministry told the villagers that they would reconstruct the houses that were destroyed and told them not to worry as it was a temporary relocation.

 

Many villagers faced difficulties at the relocation site as they had inadequate housing equipment and the newly built huts were too small for large families. Ma S--- elaborated on this problem: “These people are poor. They [the village administrator] should not have done that to them […].” Ma S--- testified that she spent 50,000 kyats [33.19 USD] to build a tent there, and elaborated on the difficulties she faced in relation to the high-cost of building the tent: “When we built it, it cost us 50,000 kyats. I had to sell goods [snacks] at the school to save money. It was for buying leaves [to make a] roof for my tent.”

 

In August 2019, villagers were allowed to return to K---. Although villagers were allocated lands in K--- after the road construction activities ceased, houses that were destroyed were not reconstructed, as promised. As of December 17th 2019, five households had returned to the village, while the others remained at the relocation site because they could not afford to rebuild their houses.

 

 

Part 4 - Permission for Using the Details

Did the victim(s) provide permission to use this information? Explain how that permission was provided. Did the victim(s) provide permission to use this information? Explain how that permission was provided. 
Did the victim(s) provide permission to use this information? Explain how that permission was provided. The victim gave KHRG permission to use the information for publication. 
Did the victim(s) provide permission to use this information? Explain how that permission was provided. 
The victim gave KHRG permission to use the information for publication. 

Hpapun Incident Report: Forced relocation by the Meh Tha Lut village administrator in Bu Tho Township, May 2019

,

These two photos were taken on May 3rd, 2019 in L--- village, Meh Klaw village tract, Bu Tho Township, Hpapun District. These two photos show the road that was constructed in K---.

 

Part 1- Incident Details

Type of IncidentType of Incident
Forced relocationForced relocation
Type of IncidentDate of Incident (s)
Forced relocationMay 1st 2019
Type of Incident

Incident Location (Village, Township and District)

Forced relocationK--- (close to L--- village), Meh K'law village tract, Bu Tho Township, Mutraw District
Type of Incident Forced relocation
Date of Incident (s) May 1st 2019

Incident Location (Village, Township and District)

K--- (close to L--- village), Meh K'law village tract, Bu Tho Township, Mutraw District
Victim InformationVictim Information
Victim InformationName
Ma S---
Victim InformationAge
43
Victim InformationSex
Female
Victim InformationEthnicity
Burmese
Victim InformationFamily
Married
Victim InformationOccupation
Day labourer 
Victim InformationReligion 
Buddhist 
Victim InformationPosition
-
Victim InformationVillage
L--- Village
Victim Information
Name Ma S---
Age 43
Sex Female
Ethnicity Burmese
Family Married
Occupation Day labourer 
Religion  Buddhist 
Position -
Village L--- Village
Perpetrator Information (Civilians) Perpetrator Information (Civilians) 
Perpetrator Information (Civilians) Name (s)
Position
Location
Superior's Name
Perpetrator Information (Civilians) U Aung Myint Kyine
Meh Tha Lut village administrator
Meh Tha Lut village, Meh K'law village tract, Hpapun Township
U Chan Nyein Aye, Bu Tho Township administrator
Perpetrator Information (Civilians) 
Name (s) Position Location Superior's Name
U Aung Myint Kyine Meh Tha Lut village administrator Meh Tha Lut village, Meh K'law village tract, Hpapun Township U Chan Nyein Aye, Bu Tho Township administrator

 

Part 2 - Information Quality 

1. Explain in detail how you collected this information.1. Explain in detail how you collected this information.
1. Explain in detail how you collected this information.Ma S--- called the KHRG researcher, who went to meet with her and interviewed her. 
1. Explain in detail how you collected this information.
Ma S--- called the KHRG researcher, who went to meet with her and interviewed her. 
2. Explain how the source verified this information. 2. Explain how the source verified this information. 
2. Explain how the source verified this information. The interviewee experienced this incident first hand. 
2. Explain how the source verified this information. 
The interviewee experienced this incident first hand. 

 

Part 3 - Complete Description for the Incident

Describe the Incident(s) in complete detail. Describe the Incident(s) in complete detail. 
Describe the Incident(s) in complete detail. 

Around April 21st 2019, three people from the Ministry of Agriculture, Livestock and Irrigation (the Ministry) and the Meh Tha Lut village administrator, U[2] Aung Myint Kyine, came to K--- to survey the area for a road construction project to improve connectivity between K--- and L--- village. At the same time, villagers were also informed of this project and promised that they would each be allocated a plot of land measuring 40 x 60 feet [approximately 12.20 x 18.30 metres] in K---. The village administrator also extorted money from villagers by asking them to pay between 10,000 to 20,000 kyats [USD 6.64 and 13.28, respectively][3] to cover the cost of the road construction activities.

 

On May 1st 2019, U Aung Myint Kyine forced 87 villagers from 13 households in K--- to relocate. Many villagers have lived in the area since 2009. Although they do not possess any land titles, they obtained consent from the Karen National Union (KNU)[4] to live there. On the same day, the three people from the Ministry and the village administrator started the construction activities with bulldozers. Although the villagers did not want to leave, they dismantled their houses and built huts on other villagers’ nearby paddy fields as they had no ability to oppose the project.

 

The dismantled houses valued at a range of 50,000 to 300,000 kyats [USD 33.19 to 199.13]; and 25% of the houses were destroyed during the dismantling process. Ma S--- stated: “We were afraid that our houses were going to be destroyed by the bulldozer if we failed to move out from our place. Actually, it was not necessary to dismantle the houses. Because of this, we faced difficulties as we are a big family. They [the village administrator] intentionally forced us to relocate from this place […].”

 

While road construction activities were carried out, U Chan Nyein Aye, the Hpapun Township administrator, came to the area to monitor the situation.  He, U Aung Myint Kyine, and the three personnel from the Ministry told the villagers that they would reconstruct the houses that were destroyed and told them not to worry as it was a temporary relocation.

 

Many villagers faced difficulties at the relocation site as they had inadequate housing equipment and the newly built huts were too small for large families. Ma S--- elaborated on this problem: “These people are poor. They [the village administrator] should not have done that to them […].” Ma S--- testified that she spent 50,000 kyats [33.19 USD] to build a tent there, and elaborated on the difficulties she faced in relation to the high-cost of building the tent: “When we built it, it cost us 50,000 kyats. I had to sell goods [snacks] at the school to save money. It was for buying leaves [to make a] roof for my tent.”

 

In August 2019, villagers were allowed to return to K---. Although villagers were allocated lands in K--- after the road construction activities ceased, houses that were destroyed were not reconstructed, as promised. As of December 17th 2019, five households had returned to the village, while the others remained at the relocation site because they could not afford to rebuild their houses.

 

Describe the Incident(s) in complete detail. 

Around April 21st 2019, three people from the Ministry of Agriculture, Livestock and Irrigation (the Ministry) and the Meh Tha Lut village administrator, U[2] Aung Myint Kyine, came to K--- to survey the area for a road construction project to improve connectivity between K--- and L--- village. At the same time, villagers were also informed of this project and promised that they would each be allocated a plot of land measuring 40 x 60 feet [approximately 12.20 x 18.30 metres] in K---. The village administrator also extorted money from villagers by asking them to pay between 10,000 to 20,000 kyats [USD 6.64 and 13.28, respectively][3] to cover the cost of the road construction activities.

 

On May 1st 2019, U Aung Myint Kyine forced 87 villagers from 13 households in K--- to relocate. Many villagers have lived in the area since 2009. Although they do not possess any land titles, they obtained consent from the Karen National Union (KNU)[4] to live there. On the same day, the three people from the Ministry and the village administrator started the construction activities with bulldozers. Although the villagers did not want to leave, they dismantled their houses and built huts on other villagers’ nearby paddy fields as they had no ability to oppose the project.

 

The dismantled houses valued at a range of 50,000 to 300,000 kyats [USD 33.19 to 199.13]; and 25% of the houses were destroyed during the dismantling process. Ma S--- stated: “We were afraid that our houses were going to be destroyed by the bulldozer if we failed to move out from our place. Actually, it was not necessary to dismantle the houses. Because of this, we faced difficulties as we are a big family. They [the village administrator] intentionally forced us to relocate from this place […].”

 

While road construction activities were carried out, U Chan Nyein Aye, the Hpapun Township administrator, came to the area to monitor the situation.  He, U Aung Myint Kyine, and the three personnel from the Ministry told the villagers that they would reconstruct the houses that were destroyed and told them not to worry as it was a temporary relocation.

 

Many villagers faced difficulties at the relocation site as they had inadequate housing equipment and the newly built huts were too small for large families. Ma S--- elaborated on this problem: “These people are poor. They [the village administrator] should not have done that to them […].” Ma S--- testified that she spent 50,000 kyats [33.19 USD] to build a tent there, and elaborated on the difficulties she faced in relation to the high-cost of building the tent: “When we built it, it cost us 50,000 kyats. I had to sell goods [snacks] at the school to save money. It was for buying leaves [to make a] roof for my tent.”

 

In August 2019, villagers were allowed to return to K---. Although villagers were allocated lands in K--- after the road construction activities ceased, houses that were destroyed were not reconstructed, as promised. As of December 17th 2019, five households had returned to the village, while the others remained at the relocation site because they could not afford to rebuild their houses.

 

 

Part 4 - Permission for Using the Details

Did the victim(s) provide permission to use this information? Explain how that permission was provided. Did the victim(s) provide permission to use this information? Explain how that permission was provided. 
Did the victim(s) provide permission to use this information? Explain how that permission was provided. The victim gave KHRG permission to use the information for publication. 
Did the victim(s) provide permission to use this information? Explain how that permission was provided. 
The victim gave KHRG permission to use the information for publication.