These two photos were taken in April 2024 at a farmland located near Z--- village, Meh Klaw village tract, Bu Tho Township, Mu Traw District. These photos show Saw H--- who was injured when physically abused by the SAC captain, named Ba Lay, from LIB #434. On April 2nd 2024, he was arrested by SAC soldiers and forced to navigate for them, alongside three other villagers, two of whom are Saw H---’s relatives. The villagers escaped on April 3rd 2024. [Photos: KHRG]
Part 1 – Incident Details
Type of Incident |
Type of Incident |
Arbitrary arrest, use of forced navigators and human shields, and physical abuse, by the State Administration Council (SAC)[2] |
Arbitrary arrest, use of forced navigators and human shields, and physical abuse, by the State Administration Council (SAC)[2] |
Type of Incident |
Date of Incident(s) |
Arbitrary arrest, use of forced navigators and human shields, and physical abuse, by the State Administration Council (SAC)[2] |
April 2nd 2024 |
Type of Incident |
Incident Location (Village, Township and District) |
Arbitrary arrest, use of forced navigators and human shields, and physical abuse, by the State Administration Council (SAC)[2] |
Z--- village, Meh Klaw village tract[3], Bu Tho Township, Mu Traw District |
Type of Incident |
Arbitrary arrest, use of forced navigators and human shields, and physical abuse, by the State Administration Council (SAC)[2] |
Date of Incident(s) |
April 2nd 2024 |
Incident Location (Village, Township and District) |
Z--- village, Meh Klaw village tract[3], Bu Tho Township, Mu Traw District |
Victims Information |
Victims Information |
Victims Information |
Name |
Saw[4] H--- | |
[Saw H---’s] youngest brother [Unknown name] | |
[Saw H---’s] nephew [Unknown name] | |
O---
|
Victims Information |
Age |
42 years old | |
Unknown | |
Unknown | |
Unknown |
Victims Information |
Gender |
Man | |
Man | |
Man | |
Man |
Victims Information |
Ethnicity |
Karen | |
Karen | |
Karen | |
Karen |
Victims Information |
Marital Status |
Married | |
Unknown | |
Unknown | |
Unknown |
Victims Information |
Occupation |
Farming (hill field) | |
Unknown | |
Unknown | |
Unknown |
Victims Information |
Religion |
Animist | |
Unknown | |
Unknown | |
Unknown |
Victims Information |
Position |
Village head | |
Villager | |
Villager | |
Villager |
Victims Information |
Village |
Z--- village, Meh Klaw village tract | |
Z--- village, Meh Klaw village tract | |
Z--- village, Meh Klaw village tract | |
Z--- village, Meh Klaw village tract |
Victims Information |
||||
Name |
Saw[4] H--- |
[Saw H---’s] youngest brother [Unknown name] |
[Saw H---’s] nephew [Unknown name] |
O---
|
Age |
42 years old |
Unknown |
Unknown |
Unknown |
Gender |
Man |
Man |
Man |
Man |
Ethnicity |
Karen |
Karen |
Karen |
Karen |
Marital Status |
Married |
Unknown |
Unknown |
Unknown |
Occupation |
Farming (hill field) |
Unknown |
Unknown |
Unknown |
Religion |
Animist |
Unknown |
Unknown |
Unknown |
Position |
Village head |
Villager |
Villager |
Villager |
Village |
Z--- village, Meh Klaw village tract |
Z--- village, Meh Klaw village tract |
Z--- village, Meh Klaw village tract |
Z--- village, Meh Klaw village tract |
Perpetrator Information (Armed Actors) |
Perpetrator Information (Armed Actors) |
Perpetrator Information (Armed Actors) |
Name(s) |
Rank | |
Unit | |
Base | |
Commander’s Name |
Perpetrator Information (Armed Actors) |
Ba Lay |
Captain | |
SAC Light Infantry Battalion (LIB)[5] #434 | |
Koo Seik army camp, Ma Htaw village tract, Dwe Lo Township, Mu Traw District | |
Unknown |
Perpetrator Information (Armed Actors) |
||||
Name(s) |
Rank |
Unit |
Base |
Commander’s Name |
Ba Lay |
Captain |
SAC Light Infantry Battalion (LIB)[5] #434 |
Koo Seik army camp, Ma Htaw village tract, Dwe Lo Township, Mu Traw District |
Unknown |
Part 2 - Information Quality
1. Explain in detail how this information was collected. |
1. Explain in detail how this information was collected. |
1. Explain in detail how this information was collected. |
A staff member from the Karen National Union (KNU)[6] township office [in Lu Thaw Township, Mu Traw District] informed a KHRG researcher about this incident via radio message. Following the incident on April 2nd 2024, the KHRG researcher went to the area to interview a local leader [specific position censored for security] and one of the victims [who is also the village head of Z--- village]. |
1. Explain in detail how this information was collected. |
A staff member from the Karen National Union (KNU)[6] township office [in Lu Thaw Township, Mu Traw District] informed a KHRG researcher about this incident via radio message. Following the incident on April 2nd 2024, the KHRG researcher went to the area to interview a local leader [specific position censored for security] and one of the victims [who is also the village head of Z--- village]. |
2. Explain how the source verified this information. |
2. Explain how the source verified this information. |
2. Explain how the source verified this information. |
Saw H--- [one of the victims, and the village head of Z--- village] provided information about his experience. |
2. Explain how the source verified this information. |
Saw H--- [one of the victims, and the village head of Z--- village] provided information about his experience. |
Part 3 – Complete Description of the Incident
Describe the Incident(s) in complete detail. |
Describe the Incident(s) in complete detail. |
Describe the Incident(s) in complete detail. |
On April 2nd 2024, more than 200 soldiers from the State Administration Council (SAC)’s Light Infantry Battalion (LIB) #434, based at Koo Seik army camp (Ma Htaw village tract, Dwe Lo Township), marched to Na Koo Nah village, Meh Klaw village tract, Bu Tho Township, and to Way Sa village, Meh Klaw village tract. [As they continued their journey, and] upon reaching Z--- village, Meh Klaw village tract, the soldiers arrested 11 villagers who they encountered on the way near Z--- village, including the village head, Saw H---, from Z--- village. The arrested villagers included Saw H---, his three children [exact ages unknown, but underage], his uncle and aunt, his father-in-law and mother-in-law, his nephew, his youngest brother, and O--- [another villager from the same village]. [Due to SAC militarisation in the area, including shelling and air strikes, these villagers had been living in the forest for about a year. They would travel back and forth from the forest to their homes in the village to check on their properties. SAC soldiers arrested them while they were traveling.] None of the villagers were informed of any reasons for their arrest.
On that day, during the same incident, the village head, Saw H---, his youngest brother, his nephew, and another villager named O--- were [separated from the other villagers and] forced [by the SAC soldiers] to navigate the way to the LIB #434 army camp. [The other seven villagers were released at this time.] The purpose [of the forced navigation] was to avoid encountering Karen National Liberation Army (KNLA)[7] combined troops along the route [and to use the villagers as human shields]. The SAC soldiers did not take his [Saw H---’s] three children, his uncle and aunt, or his mother-in-law and father-in-law with them [as human shields]. Saw H--- explained: “They [SAC soldiers] forced me to navigate a way where there would be no people [local armed resistance groups] present. The SAC soldiers said, ‘We can go [to the Koo Seik army camp] through the jungle road that you will lead. It will only be enough if we are able to reach our destination [without encountering any armed resistance groups].’ Then, I navigated the way for them.”
When they [SAC soldiers and the four villagers being used as human shields and forced navigators] reached a water channel next to a farmland [precise location unknown], sporadic fighting occurred between the SAC and KNLA soldiers. After the fighting ceased, the SAC captain, named Ba Lay, from LIB #434 threatened him [Saw H---] that if fighting happened again on their journey, he would not be able to escape and he would be killed immediately. Then, the captain kicked Saw H--- once and punched him in the face once. With that kick and punch, Saw H--- fell to the ground and cut his knee.
Saw H--- and the three other villagers were forced to accompany [and navigate for] the SAC soldiers on a journey that lasted for one day. While navigating for the soldiers along their route, they were not provided with any food or opportunity to eat. Saw H--- recalled: “I had a meal in the morning before the arrest. After I was arrested, I did not get to eat for the rest of the day. I did not get to eat the whole night and the whole morning [of the next day].”
On April 3rd 2024, when they [the four villagers being used as human shields/forced navigators] were taken to a logging place nearby the LIB #434 army camp, Saw H---, his youngest brother and nephew managed to escape. Although they managed to escape, [the other villager] O--- [who had not managed to escape], was taken [as a navigator for the SAC soldiers] to the SAC army camp where LIB #434 was based. When the SAC soldiers arrived at their army camp, they released O---, and did not torture him.
When he [Saw H---] arrived home, his wife informed him that [after they were separated], SAC soldiers [from the same LIB #434] had looted four pairs of earrings, a ring, and 10,000 baht [288.96 USD[8]] and 50,000 kyats [23.82 USD[9]] from them [Saw H---’s wife and children] in the forest near Z--- village. [Some] SAC soldiers from the same battalion [entered Z--- village and] had also broken into Saw H---’s [family] house located in Z--- village. [The SAC soldiers] had destroyed a box where they [Saw H--- and his family] kept their belongings inside and had stolen three shirts and a lucky string [which is believed to offer protection and bring good luck]. Saw H--- explained that, when he escaped and arrived back to his family, “my wife told me ‘you have three children, and I bought them two earrings [which were taken], two earrings and a ring which were given to me by their grandmother [which were also taken]. They [SAC soldiers] also confiscated 10,000 baht that we had saved. With that money, I thought I was going to send one of the children to school who has to attend grade-8 and has to stay at the dormitory.’” Saw H--- added, “my wife asked ‘how can we afford to send our children to school?’”
Saw H--- and his family felt profound sadness about what had happened to him and [worry about] the effect [this will have] on his children and their future education. He also felt like it had violated his human rights. He reported that he would like the SAC soldiers to be removed from their area, recognising that their actions are unjust. He added: “I hope to see peace in the future.” |
Describe the Incident(s) in complete detail. |
On April 2nd 2024, more than 200 soldiers from the State Administration Council (SAC)’s Light Infantry Battalion (LIB) #434, based at Koo Seik army camp (Ma Htaw village tract, Dwe Lo Township), marched to Na Koo Nah village, Meh Klaw village tract, Bu Tho Township, and to Way Sa village, Meh Klaw village tract. [As they continued their journey, and] upon reaching Z--- village, Meh Klaw village tract, the soldiers arrested 11 villagers who they encountered on the way near Z--- village, including the village head, Saw H---, from Z--- village. The arrested villagers included Saw H---, his three children [exact ages unknown, but underage], his uncle and aunt, his father-in-law and mother-in-law, his nephew, his youngest brother, and O--- [another villager from the same village]. [Due to SAC militarisation in the area, including shelling and air strikes, these villagers had been living in the forest for about a year. They would travel back and forth from the forest to their homes in the village to check on their properties. SAC soldiers arrested them while they were traveling.] None of the villagers were informed of any reasons for their arrest.
On that day, during the same incident, the village head, Saw H---, his youngest brother, his nephew, and another villager named O--- were [separated from the other villagers and] forced [by the SAC soldiers] to navigate the way to the LIB #434 army camp. [The other seven villagers were released at this time.] The purpose [of the forced navigation] was to avoid encountering Karen National Liberation Army (KNLA)[7] combined troops along the route [and to use the villagers as human shields]. The SAC soldiers did not take his [Saw H---’s] three children, his uncle and aunt, or his mother-in-law and father-in-law with them [as human shields]. Saw H--- explained: “They [SAC soldiers] forced me to navigate a way where there would be no people [local armed resistance groups] present. The SAC soldiers said, ‘We can go [to the Koo Seik army camp] through the jungle road that you will lead. It will only be enough if we are able to reach our destination [without encountering any armed resistance groups].’ Then, I navigated the way for them.”
When they [SAC soldiers and the four villagers being used as human shields and forced navigators] reached a water channel next to a farmland [precise location unknown], sporadic fighting occurred between the SAC and KNLA soldiers. After the fighting ceased, the SAC captain, named Ba Lay, from LIB #434 threatened him [Saw H---] that if fighting happened again on their journey, he would not be able to escape and he would be killed immediately. Then, the captain kicked Saw H--- once and punched him in the face once. With that kick and punch, Saw H--- fell to the ground and cut his knee.
Saw H--- and the three other villagers were forced to accompany [and navigate for] the SAC soldiers on a journey that lasted for one day. While navigating for the soldiers along their route, they were not provided with any food or opportunity to eat. Saw H--- recalled: “I had a meal in the morning before the arrest. After I was arrested, I did not get to eat for the rest of the day. I did not get to eat the whole night and the whole morning [of the next day].”
On April 3rd 2024, when they [the four villagers being used as human shields/forced navigators] were taken to a logging place nearby the LIB #434 army camp, Saw H---, his youngest brother and nephew managed to escape. Although they managed to escape, [the other villager] O--- [who had not managed to escape], was taken [as a navigator for the SAC soldiers] to the SAC army camp where LIB #434 was based. When the SAC soldiers arrived at their army camp, they released O---, and did not torture him.
When he [Saw H---] arrived home, his wife informed him that [after they were separated], SAC soldiers [from the same LIB #434] had looted four pairs of earrings, a ring, and 10,000 baht [288.96 USD[8]] and 50,000 kyats [23.82 USD[9]] from them [Saw H---’s wife and children] in the forest near Z--- village. [Some] SAC soldiers from the same battalion [entered Z--- village and] had also broken into Saw H---’s [family] house located in Z--- village. [The SAC soldiers] had destroyed a box where they [Saw H--- and his family] kept their belongings inside and had stolen three shirts and a lucky string [which is believed to offer protection and bring good luck]. Saw H--- explained that, when he escaped and arrived back to his family, “my wife told me ‘you have three children, and I bought them two earrings [which were taken], two earrings and a ring which were given to me by their grandmother [which were also taken]. They [SAC soldiers] also confiscated 10,000 baht that we had saved. With that money, I thought I was going to send one of the children to school who has to attend grade-8 and has to stay at the dormitory.’” Saw H--- added, “my wife asked ‘how can we afford to send our children to school?’”
Saw H--- and his family felt profound sadness about what had happened to him and [worry about] the effect [this will have] on his children and their future education. He also felt like it had violated his human rights. He reported that he would like the SAC soldiers to be removed from their area, recognising that their actions are unjust. He added: “I hope to see peace in the future.” |
Part 4 - Permission for Using the Details
Did the victim(s) provide permission to use this information? Explain how that permission was provided. |
Did the victim(s) provide permission to use this information? Explain how that permission was provided. |
Did the victim(s) provide permission to use this information? Explain how that permission was provided. |
Saw H--- allowed KHRG to use this information. He said international stakeholders should know this kind of incident are occurring. |
Did the victim(s) provide permission to use this information? Explain how that permission was provided. |
Saw H--- allowed KHRG to use this information. He said international stakeholders should know this kind of incident are occurring. |
Further background reading on the situation on arbitrary arrest, forced navigators, and human shields in Southeast Burma/Myanmar can be found in the following KHRG reports: