Situation Update | K’Ser Doh and Ler Muh Lah townships, Mergui-Tavoy District (December 2017 to February 2018)
The following Situation Update was received by KHRG in March 2018. It was written by a community member in Mergui-Tavoy District who has been trained by KHRG to monitor human rights conditions. It is presented below translated exactly as originally written, save for minor edits for clarity and security. This report was received along with other information from Mergui-Tavoy District, including 17 photos.
This Situation Update describes events that occurred in Kleh Muh Htee [village tract], K’ser Doh Township and M’saw [village tract], Ler Muh Lah Township, Mergui-Tavoy District. It includes information about the health conditions of internally displaced people (IDPs), corporal punishment in local schools, lead mining, drug use, logging and land confiscations.
Health Conditions of Internally Displaced People (IDPs)
[A number of local villages are host to significant numbers of IDPs, including] Maw Nee, Htee Klee Sa, T’Mah Wah, Htaw T’Lee, Htoo Maw and Ler Say Hkee in La Baw village tract area, K’Ser Doh Township, Mergui-Tavoy District. They are located in a mountainous area distant from any of the nearby towns.
IDPs require holistic support. However, healthcare services are not available in these villages. These communities find it challenging to access healthcare because of the long distance to nearby clinics and the poor conditions of the roads. During the rainy season, these communities have to pass over three rivers to reach the nearest health clinic, passing through P’law Kloh, Maw Nee and Hkeh Ma villages. They depend on local boatmen to take them over these rivers.
Corporal Punishment in local schools
There is only one high school in Aeh Aeh village, Aeh Aeh area, K’Ser Doh Township, Mergui-Tavoy Township. It has many students and teachers who come from nearby villages. The majority of students are [ethnically] Karen. Some teachers are Bamar [ethnically Burmese].
In the 2017-2018 academic year, teacher U--- physically beat students who could not follow his lesson.
A Standard Five student said:
“This teacher beats and slaps students when they cannot focus properly. One day, when some male students could not follow a lesson, the teacher asked them to lie down. He then stepped on each of them. The students cried out loud because they could not tolerate the pain.”
A standard eight student, Saw V--- said that this teacher hit him when he could not follow the lesson. [He hit him so hard that the skin on his leg broke, creating a laceration]. So far, this wound has not healed because of the strength of his teacher’s blows.
[Corporal punishment is also common in neighbouring schools]. Some teachers in La Baw village, Kleh Muh Htee, K’Ser Doh Township, were also accused of hitting students.
A local villager Naw Htee said:
“Students do not dare to tell their parents about the punishments they receive from their teachers. One evening, I washed my son’s hair when he got back from the school. He said that his head hurt. When I asked him about the cause of his pain, he said that a teacher had hit his head with a stick, bruising it in the process. I encouraged the village head to call out the teachers for their heavy punishments. I was not happy about [the situation]. The village head held a meeting with school committee members, parents and teachers to discuss corporal punishments on students. The village leaders, teachers and one of the principals resolved this issue. After the village head held this meeting, teachers stopped using corporal punishments on students.”
[In addition to the issue of corporal punishment, there is an inequality in access to education in this area]. There are 47 households in Ng’yah Aye village, M’saw area, Ler Muh Lah Township, Mergui-Tavoy District. Most of these households are displaced families who resettled in Ng’yah Aye village after the Asia World Company confiscated their land in 2000. The Burma/Myanmar government did not take action to provide education to these households. The community self-funded a primary school in order to provide education to their children. In 2018, there were 6 teachers and 67 students in this school. The community had to pay 50,000 kyat (US $ 34.6) to each teacher as a monthly salary. Many parents struggled financially to afford the cost of the teachers’ salaries.
In January 2018, many lead mining operations took place in Maw Nee, Htoo Maw, Htee Klee Sah, T’Mah Wah and Htoo Maw villages in Kleh Muh Htee, K’Ser Doh Township. [In these instances,] the workers who were running the lead mines were not locals. They did not ask for permission from the local village leaders [to mine for lead in this area]. Instead, they received a permission letter from the Karen National Liberation Army (KNLA) Battalion #12. [In total,] there are five lead mining machines. The lead mining workers have to pay a monthly tax of about 100,000 kyat (US $ 69.1) per mining machine. The KNLA Battalion #12 is receiving a monthly tax of 500,000 kyat (US $ 346) from these mining operations.
[In some places,] the lead mining operation was located near the source of local streams. This caused the water to be contaminated, creating challenges for the villagers who depend on the stream for their water supply. Local community members reported this case to the Township leaders and the KNLA Battalion #12 commander. According to a local villager, the [KNLA Battalion #12] commander resolved this problem.
The Tavoy Paung Si Company [has also] tested the lead deposits [in the local area] to evaluate whether it will start mining operations. [As of mid-2018,] it has not yet started mining for lead in the area. The Tavoy Paung Si Company proposed to start mining for lead in two areas: Operation Section #1, covering 39.5 acres of land, and Operation Section #2, covering 49.5 acres of land.
Mining is widespread in Mergui-Tavoy District. The Nay Htet Hsu Company is mining an area of 9,331 acres. The Shole Dinki Company is mining an area of 6,000 acres. [In addition to this, a huge expanse of land in the same area was designated as a reserved forest by the Burma/Myanmar government]. The reserved forest covers an area of 25,773 acres. [Because the mining operations and the newly designated reserved forest, the local community has less access to land for agriculture and grazing purposes]. According to the village head of Maw Nee, this issue was already reported this to the chief liaison of Mergui-Tavoy District.
In 2018, drug use increased throughout Mergui-Tavoy District. The most commonly used drugs are cannabis and methamphetamine [yaba]. However, it is not easy to investigate drug use. As Kyauk Taung village head noted,
“The Burma/Myanmar government does not arrest drug users even though they were aware of them. Villagers like us are not authorised to arrest drug users.”
The forest areas in the La Baw, Aeh Aeh, and Th’Nyaw Hsee village tracts are being logged for timber. In 2017, the KNLA soldier Saw Shee was involved in logging. He is originally from La Baw village, but lives in Maw Nee village, La Baw village tract, K’Ser Doh Township.
Soon after his move to Maw Nee, Saw Shee wanted to log wood to construct buildings for the village and build himself a house. After the local villagers gave him permission to log wood, he did not do as promised. Rather than constructing buildings for the village, he started running his own logging business. He gave very little timber for buildings in the village. Instead, he logged large amounts of timber transported it to the P’Law town. His logging operation did not benefit the local community in any way. A community member said that Saw Shee is logging for his own benefit - not the [benefit of the] local villagers. Large amounts of timber were transported to the town, yet no new buildings were constructed in the village.
Similarly, a villager [from a rich family] from P’Taw Hpa Doh village, Th’Nyaw Hsee area, K’Ser Doh Township requested permission to log the forest [surrounding Maw Nee village] from the Township police and the Forestry Department of the Burma/Myanmar government. He did not ask for permission from the local villagers. Even though the local community did not want him to log their forest, they were afraid of telling him that. A local villager said, “We do not want him to log [the forest] but we do not dare to tell him”. He perceived that the logging would not be beneficial to the local community.
Many people came to Maw Nee village [to look at the logging potential in the area]. They did not inform the local village leaders about their intention. In 2017, businessmen from Japan and China, as well as a retired Tatmadaw major, examined lead deposits around Maw Nee. When they were asked to meet the village leaders, they refused to do so. The local community believes that these outsiders came with the permission of Saw Shee. They would often visit Saw Shee’s house to rest. They believe that the outsiders [who come to visit Maw Nee] rely on Saw Shee because he is a KNLA soldier. Not informing the village leaders about who is going in and out of the village is a breach of local security procedures.
The Asia World Company confiscated the land of local villagers in Ng’yat Ain village, Ton Pyaw Kyi village and Ban Met village in M’Saw are, Ler Muh Lah township.
[These villagers had already been displaced by the Tatmadaw]. In October 1997, the Tatmadaw forced local villagers from their homes, [resettling them on] land close to the road to Mergui-Tavoy town. Three years later, the Asia World Company confiscated the lands that had been seized by the Tatmadaw. The company cleared grazing lands and plantations. After that, they planted palm oil trees on those lands.
The local community was afraid for their safety. They did not dare to confront the company because it was granted permission to use these lands by the Tatmadaw. The company provided compensation to the local community for lands that were damaged [due to the palm oil plantation]. However, this compensation was less than a third of the value of the confiscated land.
Local villagers tried to report this case to the Karen National Union (KNU) authorities and the Burma/Myanmar government. However, [as of March 2018], they did not receive any response from the authorities.
During the reporting period, there have been some improvements in the field of education, healthcare, transportation and development in Mergui-Tavoy District. There has been a decrease in military activities.
However, certain challenges remain. Natural resource extraction and military activities have impacted the livelihoods of local communities. Land confiscation and pollution by lead mining have damaged the water supply of many communities. This illustrates the broader tensions surrounding development in Southeast Myanmar. Villagers are worried about the impacts of corporate development projects on the environment and on their livelihoods.